We use only the best products

All Fresh, All Delicious

Say ahhhhhhh

Simply Irresistible

Welcome to
Fire Engine Pizza Co.


Fire Engine Pizza Company is Put-in-Bay's newest pizza shop! We put out great pizzas by using fresh ingredients, an amazing sauce and the best dough available. Our triple deck conveyor style oven is able to put out over 300 pizzas per hour, so there is less wait time from the time you place your order until you are consuming the island's best pizza. We offer specials, late night service and delivery too! We are located on the front porch of the Grand Islander Hotel and next to the Last Resort Engine Company.


Our Pizzas

We take pizza seriously and so should you! All of our pizzas our made fresh, with the toppings you want. We use quality ingredients every step of the way, but that doesn't mean the cost goes up. In fact, our pizzas our priced better than any other place on the island. Want something different? Try one of our specialty pizzas!

Pizza Sticks

Are you on the go and don't have time to sit down and smash a pizza? Then try one of our delicious pizza sticks. They come 4 different ways and when paired with a great dipping sauce it is just what you need to fill you up.

Delivery and Late Night

Don't want to come downtown to pick up your pizza? No problem, we'll deliver it to you. Hungry after a long day of bar hopping? Then walk on over to our shop for some late night pizza! We'll have pizza sticks available to grab and go and if you want to order a custom pizza, you can do that too.

CALL US NOW 419-515-2645